We want to live more naturally, without exposure to everyday carcinogens.

Join us as we research and source healthier and sustainably made products for the home.

Menu  

Organic Mattress Comparison Chart

We have different certified organic mattress options based on our customer's needs but deciding which option can be difficult.

We hope this presents the important factors that you need to take into account to make an informed decision on what's important to you - potential allergy concerns, waterproofing vs exposure to plastic and/or price.

 Naturepedic's Waterproof 2in1 Ultra Kids / crib mattressNaturepedic's Quilted Innerspring Kids / Crib MattressOrganic Lifestyle's Crib Innerspring Mattress - essential, premium versionOrganic Lifestyle's Crib rubber latex mattress
POSITIONINGBuilt-in options for bed wettersGood for bunk bed; No latex rubber or woolOur highest quality innerspring; Made in CanadaMade in Canada, non-innerspring alternative, dustmite resistant (hypoallergenic)
     
Outer SurfaceTop Side:
Organic Cotton Fabric with Clear Food Grade Polyethylene Coating

Bottom Side:
Quilted Organic 
Cotton Fabric

2 sided version -

Organic Cotton Quilted Fabric all around.

1 sided version -

Top: Organic Cotton Quilted Fabric

Bottom: Just a flat surface, it's not meant to be slept on and the mattress cannot be flipped

Quilted Organic 
Cotton Fabric
Quilted Organic 
Cotton Fabric
Non-Toxic Fire ProtectionUse materials such as organic cotton fabric, organic cotton batting, plant-based non-GMO PLA batting, and steel innersprings in place of memory foam, other forms of polyurethane foam and synthetic fabrics that have much higher fuel loads. 

These materials tend to smolder instead of bursting into flames with very high heat release. This unique and innovative approach provides a simple and elegant solution that meets all US Federal and State flammability standards without the need for any fire retardant chemicals or flame retardant barriers. 

What’s In a Naturepedic Organic Mattress?
Use materials such as organic cotton fabric, organic cotton batting, plant-based non-GMO PLA batting, and steel innersprings in place of memory foam, other forms of polyurethane foam and synthetic fabrics that have much higher fuel loads.

These materials tend to smolder instead of bursting into flames with very high heat release. This unique and innovative approach provides a simple and elegant solution that meets all US Federal and State flammability standards without the need for any fire retardant chemicals or flame retardant barriers. 

What’s In a Naturepedic Organic Mattress?
Organic Wool acts as a natural fire retardantOrganic Wool acts as a natural fire retardant
Medium - Firm SupportFIRM support via Innerspring coilsFIRM support via Innerspring coils
FIRM support via Innerspring coilsMEDIUM support via Natural rubber core
Slat Foundation AvailableYesYesYesYes
Waterproof?Yes, waterproof Food-Grade Polyethylene on one side.No, Requires Add-Ons like mattress padsNo, Requires Add-Ons like mattress padsNo, Requires Add-Ons like mattress pads
Contains PlasticYes, Food-Grade Polyethylene that provides waterproofingNoneNoneNone
     
Dust Mite Safe?Yes, contains barrier cover on Top and Side.NoNoYes, as Natural Rubber isn't a good food source for dust-mites.
Latex / Rubber Allergy ConcernsNo RubberNo RubberNo RubberIndirect Rubber exposure
Wool Allergy ConcernsNo WoolNo WoolContains Wool Indirect Wool exposure
Vinyl / PVC ConcernsNoneNoneNoneNone
Polyurethane Foam ConcernsNoNoNoNo
     
Toxic Chemicals exposure
(phthalates, biocides, PBDEs, pesticides etc.)
NoneNoneNoneNone
     
CertificationGOTS
Greenguard
GOTS
Greenguard
GOTSGOTS
Country of Manufacture (affects shipping)USAUSACanadaCanada
Warranty20 year20 year10 year10 year

Back to Organic Mattress Page

Color IColor IIColor IIIColor IVColor VColor VI